Furkan Naci Top
ISTANBUL
A wealthy woman in Istanbul calls a private detective over a mind-boggling mystery in which she thinks intruders are breaking into her house.
Resat Topaloglu, a 51-year-old veteran private eye, started investigating and found "weird" liquid materials in various parts of the house and on the woman's clothes in her wardrobe.
But when the case was closed, it was the family's randy dog which emerged as the culprit, rather than mysterious interlopers.
This story is one of the more unusual cases that Topaloglu – one of the oldest detectives in the sector – has had in his career, which began in 1999 with just one partner.
The image of the private detective is heavily influenced by Hollywood with the investigator is usually depicted as a chain-smoking loner in a trench coat.
That picture has changed in recent years. Topaloglu operates from an office in Bakirkoy, Istanbul with eight other detectives – all former officers in the police or military intelligence departments.
Clients have changed. Corporations – local or global – are coming to private eyes for a variety of reasons, including spying on their employees, finding stolen property or locating where counterfeits of their products are made.
A major Turkish truck company, a high-profile instant-coffee producer, top-end car distributors, shampoo makers and even governmental institutions are just some of the clients to be found in modern Turkish detective’s customer portfolio.
In 2014, Topaloglu’s colleagues – as usual working in pairs from his InvesTurk private detectives office – started investigating the Turkish distributor of a German lock brand following a tip-off about counterfeiting.
"It was the company's own deputy CEO," says Topaloglu. The executive was identified as the ringleader of the scam after a month-long investigation.
One fifth of corporations that apply for Topaloglu's services are foreign, with a hike in the last five years as "Turkey is now more open to the world," says the investigator.
"Our foreign customers usually want to gather more information about the market or seek an investigation into their partners in the country," says Topaloglu.
Mehmet Uzuner, who runs an investigations office in Istanbul, Ankara, Izmir and Antalya, has plotted a similar course since 2003 when he became a detective after earning a law degree and studying criminology in England.
Uzuner says that 10 years ago almost all of their clients were divorcees who wanted to prove their suspicions, catching out cheating husbands and wives.
"It is not all about domestic affairs anymore," says Uzuner.
He took on one case over a fleet of cars which disappeared after being leased in Istanbul three months ago.
The luxury cars, "from one of the top brands in Europe," were found in Syria's Aleppo province, in a rebel-held region after an investigation by his team, mostly consisting of former police or military men.
"The hustlers wanted to sell it back at a lower price," says Uzuner as the insurance company did not cover the cars’ loss.
Uzuner also worked with Turkey's energy market regulator between 2006 and 2007, inspecting businesses suspected of filling domestic gas canisters illegally.
Despite the boom in business since the second half of the 2000s and their passion for their profession, there are still major problems for private eyes.
Turkey has no specific law regulating the affairs of private detectives, so it is fair to say that "only current laws and our ethic codes bind us," according to Uzuner, who is also head of Turkey’s Private Detectives’ Association.
"There is no mechanism to inspect me. Who will watch us? This is the biggest problem in this job. We act upon the existing law and our ethical code," he adds.
Draft legislation submitted more than 20 years ago to resolve this grey area was turned down by then-president Suleyman Demirel, based on its inconsistency with other laws.
Corrupt investigators that abuse and blackmail customers create another problem for the sector.
More than 20 victims of fraud each month appeal to Uzuner’s association, he says.
Unscrupulous detectives usually take fees upfront from women who want investigators to spy on their spouses over suspected cheating.
Then the detective either blackmails the client by threatening to tell the spouse or secretly revealing to the cheating partner that they have been caught, forcing them to pay up.
Uzuner thinks a law could prevent rotten detectives from defrauding people and tarnishing the private investigation sector.
Those corrupt detectives often also hint at their ability to use illegal information-gathering techniques such as wiretapping or using computer malware – which are felonies under Turkish law.
If these detectives cannot access these purported techniques then they are also lying to their clients, according to Uzuner.
Topaloglu also urges the authorities to fill the judicial vacuum, since "not everybody can or should do this job."
There are hundreds of private eyes that you can reach with an online search but, both detectives interviewed by The Anadolu Agency put the number of credible investigators in the sector at less than 10.
"The image of private detectives as only good for spying on significant others, in the eyes of politicians and reflected on media, is not helpful to our profession," says Uzuner.
High-ranking officials and jet-set celebrities put their confidence in Turkish private eyes every day, says Topaloglu.
The image of the business is improving as trainee investigators can take classes in Kocaeli University, in western Turkey, since 2007 and can obtain a private certificate in criminology and investigation.
Trainees can be lectured by former senior security force members, according to Uzuner.
Despite all this, detectives are satisfied with their tough jobs and lives, feeling that they can recommend their profession to their children.
"I have two sons and wish one of them study law to take this profession even further," says Uzuner who, like Topaloglu, who enjoys his job.
They will continue to be asked for unusual requests from new clients – like those in Turkey who want to know “who put an evil eye on me.”
But reliable private detectives in Turkey are earning more every year and the face of their profession is changing.
